Judy Blume meets Flannery O'Connor?
Dear Readers,
Though never a faithful diarist, I did journal during one especially intense month in high school. At the time, I fancied myself a teen prodigy, tortured by godly gifts of writerly expressiveness (and a totally dramatic life). I’m not sure how those particular entries would hold up today, but there is an exciting creative rawness during adolescence; and once in a blue moon, a histrionic, hormone-addled mind can, rather miraculously, reap uncanny, incandescent art.
That’s how I feel about the funny, lyrical, beautiful Miss American Pie, an astonishingly artful collection of actual diaries kept by Margaret Sartor of Montgomery, Alabama, from 1972 to 1977, ages 12 to 18. As transfixing photos show, Margaret was blond, blue-eyed, pretty enough to actually become Homecoming Queen. She was also smart, free-spirited, and profoundly inquisitive. She relished horseback riding, lolled on a raft on the bayou, entertained and rejected Christian evangelism. In the Deep South, she watched as national issues unfolded locally: desegregation, Vietnam, the sexual revolution, Watergate. She ached as she fell in and out of love (who didn’t?), as her dysfunctional family (whose isn’t?) ebbed and flowed with the humidity. She records it all here vividly with a precocious, Gothic-tinged spontaneity that, to me, reveals an artist on the verge of becoming herself; it’s like Judy Blume fused with Flannery O’Connor, with traces of the idiosyncratic, tragicomic memoirs (Jesus Land, The Glass Castle, Running with Scissors) I’ve always savored. This is an enthralling, read-it-repeatedly work which both belies and embodies the youth of its author.
—Justin Ravitz, Associate Editor, QPB
